Managed IT (MSP) vs. Hiring an In-House IT Manager: How Chicago Businesses Should Decide
The short answer: hiring one IT manager gives you a person; a managed IT provider gives you a team. A single hire fits a company that needs someone on site every day. A managed IT plan fits most businesses that want help desk, security and strategy covered all year. If you already have IT staff and want backup, co-managed IT is the middle path.
The full cost of a hire is more than a salary
When you compare an IT manager with a managed IT plan, count everything the hire brings with it:
- Recruiting fees and the time it takes to fill the role
- Benefits, payroll taxes and bonus
- Training and certifications
- The tools one administrator still needs: remote management, backup, security stack, documentation and ticketing
- Ramp-up time before the person knows your environment
- The manager’s time spent overseeing the work, and the cost of turnover and re-hiring
- Your own downtime while they are out
Our own plan is one price range, $150 to $225 per user per month, with the licenses for our security and protection tools included. See the pricing page for what is and is not included.
Coverage gaps
One person cannot cover vacations, sick days, nights and weekends, and cannot be in two offices at once. When that person leaves, the passwords and the documentation leave with them unless someone has kept them current. A team removes that single point of failure.
Breadth of skills
One generalist is rarely strong in help desk, networking, Microsoft 365, security, compliance and strategy at once. A managed IT team brings people for each of those areas, and our Fractional CIO add-on (quoted separately) covers technology planning and budgeting.
Security and compliance
Good security needs separation of duties: the person who runs your systems should not be the only one checking them. Monitoring runs 24/7, and our team keeps the evidence that clients and insurers ask for. See how this applies to law firms, financial firms and manufacturers.
Co-managed IT: the middle path
If you already have internal IT, you do not have to choose. With co-managed IT, your team keeps the work it does best, and we manage tools, security, network and updates and act as the escalation bench. It typically fits organizations with 150 to 1,000 users. The split is adapted to each client.
When hiring makes sense
Hire in-house when you need constant on-site presence, run a very large or highly specialized environment, develop your own applications, or have an existing team that only needs to grow. In those cases we recommend adding co-managed IT rather than choosing all or nothing.
Your IT person is leaving: a 30-day handover plan
- Secure every admin account and credential, and record who holds them.
- Collect and update documentation: network diagrams, licenses, renewal dates and vendor contacts.
- Confirm that backups are running and that a restore has been tested.
- Plan offboarding: remove the person’s access on their last day.
- Choose who takes over day-to-day support, then bring us in early. Our onboarding follows the 90-day plan on the How It Works page.
Decision checklist
Answer yes or no. Several “no” answers point toward managed or co-managed IT.
- Can one person cover your help desk and security?
- Is someone covering when your IT person is out?
- Is your documentation current?
- Is there a budget for the tools an IT team needs?
- Do you need coverage outside 8 to 5?
- Do you have more than one site?
- Do you have a compliance duty such as ABA, SEC, FTC Safeguards or CMMC?
- Do you need strategy, or just support?
What you get with us
- Help desk Monday to Friday, 7am to 7pm Central Time, with monitoring 24/7. After hours, urgent issues get a best-effort on-call response.
- From January 1 to November 1, 2026, our technicians started working on critical tickets in 9.6 minutes on average and on high-priority tickets, such as one person who cannot work, in 12.9 minutes. Written targets are 1 / 2 / 4 business hours and 1 business day; targets are goals, not guarantees. See service levels.
- A Service Warranty in our Master Services Agreement: if our service falls short and we cannot correct it, you can end the service.
- One plan. Projects are quoted separately; see how we handle projects.
- Recognition on the CRN MSP 500 list (2024, 2025), the Channel Futures MSP 501 (2024) and the Inc. 5000 (2024). See our recognition page.
Frequently asked questions
Does outsourcing IT cost less than hiring an IT manager?
It depends on what you count. A hire costs more than a salary: recruiting, benefits, payroll taxes, training, tools, ramp-up and the cost of replacing the person if they leave. Our managed IT plan is one price range, $150 to $225 per user per month, and the licenses for our security and protection tools are included. Use the cost factors on this page and our pricing page to compare it with your own numbers.
What does a managed IT provider do that one IT employee can’t?
A managed IT team covers help desk, networking, Microsoft 365, security, compliance and strategy with different people, so the business does not depend on one person’s skills or calendar. Monitoring of servers, networks and backups runs 24/7, and nobody audits their own work.
What is co-managed IT, and who is it for?
Co-managed IT is for companies that already have internal IT staff and want a partner behind them. Your team keeps the work it does best, and we add tools, security, network management, updates and an escalation bench. It typically fits organizations with 150 to 1,000 users.
Can we keep our IT person and still work with CIO Landing?
Yes. That is what co-managed IT is. Your IT person stays your point of contact inside the company, and we take on the parts you choose. The split is adapted to each client.
Our IT manager just gave notice. How fast can you take over?
Tell us the notice date as early as you can. We start by securing credentials and admin accounts, collecting documentation and checking backups, then follow our 90-day onboarding plan. The earlier we start, the more your outgoing person can hand over.
Will we still get on-site support?
On-site support is not part of the monthly plan. On-site work outside the plan is billed separately, and projects are quoted separately.
What happens after hours and on weekends?
The help desk is open Monday to Friday, 7am to 7pm Central Time. Monitoring of servers, networks and backups runs 24/7. After hours, urgent issues get a best-effort on-call response.
When does hiring in-house make more sense?
When you need someone on site every day, run a very large or highly specialized environment, or develop your own applications. Even then, most companies are better served by an in-house hire plus co-managed IT than by a hire alone.
Next step
Not sure which option fits? Take the cybersecurity self-assessment or contact us to talk it through.
Related guides
Comparing providers? Read how to choose a managed IT provider. Already have a provider? See how to switch managed IT providers.